type,category,item,points,details pillar,agencies,Verified reputation,30,"Bayesian rating across Google and third party sources (12), volume on a log scale (8), recency in the last 12 months (5), owner engagement (5). Clutch verified reviews weigh 2x a Yelp review." pillar,agencies,Proof of work,20,"Named case studies with numbers and a link (10, max 2 each; anonymous Client A caps at 2 total; older than 2 years weigh half), named client list or portfolio (5), awards and certifications verified on the issuer site only (5)" pillar,agencies,Service focus and transparency,15,"Share of services in the ranked category (7), pricing transparency (4), real team page with names address phone email (4)" pillar,agencies,Existence and stability,15,"Domain age via RDAP (5), business age cross checked (5), name address phone consistency (5)" pillar,agencies,Website and SEO health,10,"Free checks only: PageSpeed Insights mobile, HTTPS, mobile friendly, schema present, no broken homepage. Own search visibility is never scored." pillar,agencies,Sentiment and complaints,10,"Net sentiment from verified review text (6, minimum 10 reviews with text), complaint ratio (4)" pillar,tools,Capability and accuracy,30,"Hands on test by us with a dated test log (10), accuracy against known benchmarks (10), coverage and depth (10)" pillar,tools,Free value,20,"What the free tier genuinely gives (12), free tier usable for real work not a teaser (8). Paid only features are listed, never scored." pillar,tools,Verified reputation,20,"Written reviews Bayesian 2 or more sources with recency decay (12), volume on a log scale (5), recency (3). Product Hunt upvotes do not count. Chrome Web Store ratings need 100 or more." pillar,tools,Ease of use,15,"No signup to try the core feature (5), speed and clarity of the interface (5), docs and support quality (5)" pillar,tools,Trust and freshness,15,"Privacy (5), security (3), actively maintained last update under 6 months (4), support responsiveness (3)" pillar,experts,Verified results,30,"Named client outcomes with numbers and a linkable source (15), consistency across 2 or more clients and 2 or more years (10), a result in the last 2 years (5)" pillar,experts,Client reviews and sentiment,25,"Verified client reviews Bayesian (12), volume (5), recency (4), net sentiment from review text (4)" pillar,experts,Experience and authority,20,"Years in the field verifiable (5), public proof with links (8), certifications verified on the issuer site only (4), peer recognition (3)" pillar,experts,Identity and transparency,15,"Real name photo LinkedIn personal website (7), pricing public or a stated range (4), location and availability stated (4)" pillar,experts,Conduct and reliability,10,"Responsiveness to enquiries (4), no unresolved public complaints (3), clear engagement terms guarantee or refund policy (3)" gate,agencies,G1 Exists,,"Live HTTPS site, Google Business Profile with matching name address and phone, real identity from the registry where one exists" gate,agencies,G2 Identity verified,,"Name address and phone match across website, Google Business Profile, and LinkedIn. Domain email matches." gate,agencies,G3 Reviews verified,,"3 or more reviews from 2 or more independent sources, no burst pattern, no self reviews" gate,agencies,G4 Claimed,,"Owner claims the profile with a domain email or Google Business Profile or LinkedIn proof. Claimed subjects can correct data and never edit their score." gate,tools,T1 Exists,,"Live, works, and a real free tier with no fake free that demands a card" gate,tools,T2 Identity,,"The company behind it is named and a privacy policy is present" gate,tools,T3 Reviews verified,,"Reviews from 2 or more independent sources and no burst pattern" gate,experts,E1 Identity verified,,"Real name, photo, LinkedIn, and website, all matching" gate,experts,E2 Proof,,"At least one named client result with a source" gate,experts,E3 Reviews verified,,"3 or more verified client reviews from 2 or more independent sources and no burst pattern" tier,all,Listed not ranked,Below 40,"Below the category minimum to rank, or failed the first gate. Shown alphabetically, with no rank number." tier,all,Listed,40 to 59,"Passed the first gate and scored 40 or more. Rank number shown. No badge." tier,all,Verified,60 to 74,"Passed the identity gate and scored 60 or more. Badge: Identity Verified." tier,all,Highly Rated,75 to 89,"Passed the identity and reviews gates and scored 75 or more. Badge: Reviews Verified." tier,all,Top Rated,90 to 100,"Passed the identity and reviews gates, scored 90 or more, and met the category extras. Maximum 3 per list page." rule,all,01 Verified beats self reported,,"Self reported claims score zero unless an independent source corroborates them." rule,all,02 Bayesian averages everywhere,,"Rating sub scores use (n x rating + 10 x 4.0) / (n + 10)." rule,all,03 Recency decay,,"Reviews older than 2 years weigh 50 percent. Older than 3 years weigh 0 for reputation." rule,all,04 Two source rule,,"A reputation claim counts at full weight only when 2 or more independent sources agree." rule,all,05 Burst flag,,"10 or more reviews in 7 days with no prior history holds a subject from Top Rated and Highly Rated until a manual review clears it." rule,all,06 Negative signals count,,"Complaints, unresolved complaints, refund disputes, and unanswered negative reviews subtract points." rule,all,07 Time gate,,"Top Rated needs 12 months of review history. New entrants cap at Verified." rule,all,08 No vanity metrics,,"Follower counts, upvotes, featured in logos, pay to play award badges, and traffic estimates do not count." rule,all,09 Incentivized reviews are discounted,,"Disclosed incentivized reviews weigh 50 percent. Undisclosed incentivized reviews weigh 0 and flag the subject." rule,all,10 No pay to rank,,"Sponsored is a separate band. Never a rank boost, never a badge, never a verdict change." rule,all,11 Public breakdown and monthly recompute,,"Every profile shows score, tier, last verified date, and a per pillar breakdown with source links. Scores are recomputed monthly." minimum,agencies,To be ranked,,"10 or more total verified reviews across all sources" minimum,tools,To be ranked,,"Hands on test completed and 10 or more verified third party reviews, or 500 or more Chrome Web Store ratings" minimum,experts,To be ranked,,"E1, E2, and E3 all passed" minimum,agencies,To reach Top Rated,,"25 or more reviews, 2 or more case studies, 3 or more years old, 12 months of review history, no open burst flag, net sentiment at least 70 percent positive" minimum,tools,To reach Top Rated,,"Hands on test in the last 6 months, 12 months of review history, no open burst flag" minimum,experts,To reach Top Rated,,"5 or more verified client reviews, 2 or more named results, 3 or more years of verifiable experience, 12 months of review history, no open burst flag"