Link copied

Methodology

How RankProof ranks agencies, tools, and experts

Every score is a RankProof Score from 0 to 100. Every point has a source link and a verified date. If we can't verify something, it scores zero and the profile says so.

LAST RECOMPUTED NOV 20, 2026 / RECOMPUTED MONTHLY / VERSION 1.0

EXAMPLE DATA, NOT A REAL AGENCY

0/100

RANKPROOF SCORE

HIGHLY RATED

Example score for one agency profile.

Verified reputation24/30
Proof of work16/20
Service focus and transparency12/15
Existence and stability12/15
Website and SEO health8/10
Sentiment and complaints6/10

Score anatomy

01 / OUR PROMISE

Only facts we can verify move a score

A score has to survive a reader clicking every source link. We never invent a review, a client, a price, or a result. If a fact can't be verified, it scores zero.

Every point has a source.

Each score point links to a source URL and shows the date we verified it.

Verified beats self reported.

What a company says about itself scores zero unless an independent source agrees.

Money can't buy rank.

Sponsored listings sit in a separate, labeled band. They never change a score, a badge, or a verdict.

FOLLOW ONE POINT TO ITS SOURCE

EXAMPLE DATA

See where this appears on a real profile (Soon)

02 / THE SCORING

Three categories, three scorecards

Agencies, tools, and experts are scored on different evidence. The rules in section 04 apply to all three.

Verified reputation 30Proof of work 20Service focus and transparency 15Existence and stability 15Website and SEO health 10Sentiment and complaints 10 TOTAL 100

G1

Exists

Live HTTPS site, Google Business Profile with matching name, address, and phone, and a real identity from the registry where one exists.

PASSED

G2

Identity verified

Name, address, and phone match across website, Google Business Profile, and LinkedIn. Domain email matches.

PASSED

G3

Reviews verified

3 or more reviews from 2 or more independent sources, no burst pattern, no self reviews.

PASSED

G4

Claimed

The owner claims the profile with a domain email or Google Business Profile or LinkedIn proof. Claimed subjects can correct data and never edit their score.

PASSED

Failed state: a gray NOT PASSED tag replaces the navy tag, and the subject stops at that gate.

To be ranked

  • 10 or more total verified reviews across all sources.
  • Below 10, an agency is listed alphabetically at the bottom and not ranked.

To reach Top Rated

  • 25 or more reviews
  • 2 or more case studies
  • 3 or more years old
  • 12 months of review history
  • No open burst flag
  • Net sentiment at least 70 percent positive

03 / TIERS

Five tiers, one scale

Every category uses the same tiers. A score alone is not enough: each tier also needs its gates.

40 60 75 90

78 / 100 · Highly Rated

Below 40 or below the minimum: Listed, not ranked · 40 to 59 Listed · 60 to 74 Verified · 75 to 89 Highly Rated · 90 to 100 Top Rated

Listed, not ranked

Below 40

Below the category minimum to rank, or failed the first gate. Shown alphabetically, with no rank number.

Needs: First gate

Listed

40 to 59

Passed the first gate and scored 40 or more. Rank number shown. No badge.

Needs: First gate

Verified

60 to 74

Passed the identity gate and scored 60 or more. Badge: Identity Verified.

Needs: Identity gate

Highly Rated

75 to 89

Passed the identity and reviews gates and scored 75 or more. Badge: Reviews Verified.

Needs: Identity gateReviews gate

Top Rated

90 to 100

Passed the identity and reviews gates, scored 90 or more, and met the category extras. Maximum 3 per list page.

25 or more reviews, 2 or more case studies, 3 or more years old, 12 months of review history, no open burst flag, net sentiment at least 70 percent positive.

Needs: Identity gateReviews gateCategory extras

Identity Verified: The subject passed the identity gate: name, address, and phone match across independent sources. Reviews Verified: The subject passed the reviews gate: verified reviews from 2 or more independent sources. Sponsored never buys a badge. See the gates →

04 / THE RULES

Eleven rules that apply to every score

These rules decide how evidence is counted. They protect rankings from small samples, old reviews, fake reviews, and launch spikes.

Rating sub scores use (n × rating + 10 × 4.0) ÷ (n + 10). A 5.0 from 3 reviews must not beat a 4.8 from 200 reviews. Small samples are discounted, not rewarded.

Example: A 5.0 from 3 reviews adjusts to 4.23. A 4.8 from 200 reviews adjusts to 4.76.

05 / SENTIMENT

Sentiment comes from what reviewers wrote, not the stars

A five star review that says slow replies but good work is mixed. We classify the text, then show the split and the themes.

1

Source

Verified review text only: Google, Clutch, GoodFirms, G2, Capterra, Chrome Web Store, and LinkedIn recommendations from real client profiles. Never testimonials from the subject own site. Never text older than 3 years.

2

Classify

Each review is classified positive, neutral, or negative from its text.

3

Extract themes

Recurring themes are found by keyword frequency: communication, results, pricing, speed, reporting, support.

4

Show the output

A positive, neutral, and negative split, the top 3 themes, and the single most repeated complaint if one exists.

EXAMPLE DATA

What the profile shows

78% positive 14% neutral 8% negative

Across 112 verified reviews: 78% positive, 14% neutral, 8% negative.

Most mentioned: communicationresultsreporting

Most repeated complaint: pricing

THE MINIMUM

10

verified reviews with text are required to show a sentiment split.

Too few verified reviews to judge sentiment.

We say this instead of guessing.

Sentiment feeds the Sentiment pillar and The Verdict. Every output is produced by rules from the data, never written by hand.

08 / CORRECTIONS

How a score gets corrected

Scores are recomputed every month. If a fact is wrong, send evidence and we fix it. We don't change a score on request.

Dispute a score

  1. 1Find the factOpen the profile breakdown and find the source link or the missing data.
  2. 2Send evidenceSubmit a link that shows the correct fact. A claimed profile can also correct its own data.
  3. 3We verifyWe check the evidence against an independent source.
  4. 4The score updatesIf the evidence holds, the score is corrected with the new source and a new verified date. The change is logged.

Claimed owners can correct data. They can never edit a score.

Methodology changelog

VERSION 1.0
Nov 20, 2026 NEW RankProof v1.0 publishedAgency, tool, and expert scorecards, the Verdict, and the sponsored policy.
Nov 20, 2026 CHANGED Agency score hardenedReputation is now one pillar. Sentiment is its own pillar. Proof of work carries more weight. Case studies decay with age.
Download the rubric (CSV) View all changes (Soon)
RECOMPUTEDMonthly LAST RUNNov 20, 2026 NEXT RUNDec 20, 2026

QUESTIONS

Questions about our rankings

No. Sponsored listings sit in a separate band and never change an organic rank, a score, a badge, or a verdict.

See a score in action

Open any profile to see its breakdown, source links, and The Verdict.

Browse ranked agencies Try the free tools (Soon) List your agency (Soon)

QUESTIONS ABOUT OUR METHOD: methodology@seoranking.io

Browse ranked agencies